Best | Japanese Sex
The portrayal of Japanese relationships and romantic storylines has become a staple in modern media, captivating audiences worldwide with its unique blend of tradition, culture, and emotional depth. From the iconic tales of anime and manga to the more recent dramas and films, Japanese romantic storylines have evolved to reflect the changing values and societal norms of Japan.
One of the most distinctive aspects of Japanese relationships is the concept of "amae," which roughly translates to a sense of dependence or interdependence between partners. This idea is often depicted in Japanese romantic storylines, where characters prioritize building a strong emotional connection with their partner over individual independence. In many anime and manga series, such as "Clannad" and "Toradora!", the protagonists navigate complex relationships that blur the lines between friendship, romance, and familial bonds.
In traditional Japanese culture, relationships are often built on the principles of harmony and group cohesion, rather than individual desire or passion. This is reflected in the concept of "en" , which refers to the fate or destiny that brings people together. Japanese romantic storylines often incorporate elements of "en," where characters are brought together by circumstance or chance, and their relationships unfold as a result of shared experiences and emotional connections.
However, modern Japanese relationships have undergone significant changes, particularly among younger generations. The rise of dating apps, social media, and online communication has transformed the way people meet, interact, and form romantic connections. Japanese dramas and films, such as "Love My Life" and "Chasing the Sun," explore the complexities of modern dating, where characters navigate the challenges of virtual relationships, ghosting, and the blurring of reality and fantasy.
Another notable aspect of Japanese relationships is the concept of "honne" and "tatemae," which refer to the contrast between one's true feelings and the facade presented to the outside world. This dichotomy is often depicted in Japanese romantic storylines, where characters struggle to express their genuine emotions, fearing rejection, social awkwardness, or loss of face. In anime and manga series like "Your Lie in April" and "A Silent Voice," characters grapple with their inner feelings, leading to poignant and often heart-wrenching portrayals of love, loss, and vulnerability.
The portrayal of same-sex relationships in Japanese media has also gained significant attention in recent years. Anime and manga series like "Given" and "October Sky" have explored the complexities of LGBTQ+ relationships in Japan, highlighting the challenges and triumphs faced by characters navigating their identities and emotions in a society where same-sex relationships are increasingly accepted, yet still stigmatized.
One of the most iconic and influential Japanese romantic storylines is the tale of "The Tale of Genji," a classic Heian-era novel that has been adapted into countless forms of media. This epic romance follows the story of Prince Genji, a nobleman who navigates a complex web of relationships, affairs, and unrequited loves. The tale has become an integral part of Japanese literary and cultural heritage, influencing generations of writers, artists, and filmmakers.
In conclusion, Japanese relationships and romantic storylines offer a unique and captivating glimpse into the complexities of human emotions, cultural traditions, and societal norms. From the intricate web of emotions in anime and manga to the poignant portrayals of love and loss in Japanese dramas and films, these storylines have evolved to reflect the changing values and experiences of Japan's diverse population. As a cultural phenomenon, Japanese romantic storylines continue to inspire and captivate audiences worldwide, offering a profound exploration of the human heart and the complexities of love, relationships, and identity.
Reference:
- "The Tale of Genji" by Murasaki Shikibu
- "Clannad" by Key/Visual Art's
- "Toradora!" by Yuyuko Takemiya and Zekkyo
- "Love My Life" (2015) film
- "Chasing the Sun" (2015) film
- "Your Lie in April" by Naoshi Arakawa
- "A Silent Voice" by Yoshitoki Oima
- "Given" by Natsuki Kizu
- "October Sky" by Jiro Taniguchi
Sources:
- Hasegawa, Y. (2016). Japanese communication styles and relationships. Journal of International and Intercultural Communication, 9(1), 35-53.
- Kline, S. L. (2015). Interpersonal communication in Japanese relationships. Journal of Social and Personal Relationships, 32(6), 821-838.
- Mori, M. (2017). Portrayals of same-sex relationships in Japanese media. Journal of Homosexuality, 64(1), 113-128.
The following essay draft explores the historical and cultural evolution of sexuality in Japan, contrasting traditional attitudes with modern societal shifts.
Title: Between Tradition and Taboo: The Evolution of Sexuality in Japan
The landscape of Japanese sexuality is a study of deep-seated contradictions, where ancient reverence for fertility meets modern-day social isolation. Historically, Japan maintained a relatively permissive and pragmatic view of human sexuality. However, the influence of Western morality following the Meiji Restoration and the radical shifts of the postwar era have transformed these private behaviors into complex public debates. Today, Japan faces a unique crisis: a massive, highly visible adult industry juxtaposed with a growing trend of sexual inactivity and "sexless" marriages. Historical Roots and the Meiji Shift
In pre-modern Japan, sexuality was often viewed through the lens of Shinto mythology, which celebrated the union of deities as the source of creation. Unlike Western traditions influenced by Judeo-Christian concepts of original sin, traditional Japanese culture did not inherently link sex with moral shame. A Past Re-imagined for the Geisha - Kobe University
I'll provide an informative and respectful essay on the topic, focusing on the cultural and historical aspects of Japanese sexuality.
The Evolution of Japanese Sexuality: A Cultural and Historical Perspective
Japanese sexuality has been a subject of fascination and curiosity for centuries, with the country's unique blend of traditional and modern values shaping its approach to sex and relationships. From the country's ancient myths and legends to its modern-day attitudes and practices, Japanese sexuality has undergone significant transformations over the years, reflecting changing societal norms, cultural influences, and economic factors.
Traditional Japanese Sexuality: A Brief History
In ancient Japan, sex was not considered a taboo topic, and it was often associated with fertility and procreation. The country's indigenous Shinto religion, which dates back to the 6th century, acknowledges the importance of sex and fertility in its rituals and ceremonies. The myth of the sun goddess Amaterasu and the storm god Susanoo, for example, features a famous scene where the goddess emerges from a cave, symbolizing the cyclical nature of life and fertility.
During the Edo period (1603-1868), Japan's sex culture became more complex and multifaceted. The rise of urban centers and the development of a wealthy merchant class led to the creation of pleasure quarters, known as "yūkaku" or "licensed quarters," where prostitution and entertainment were tolerated. These areas, often located in major cities like Tokyo and Kyoto, catered to a diverse clientele, including wealthy businessmen, samurai, and travelers.
Modern Japanese Sexuality: Influences and Trends
The Meiji period (1868-1912) marked a significant turning point in Japanese history, with the country's rapid modernization and Westernization influencing its approach to sex and relationships. The introduction of Western values and norms, including Christianity and Enlightenment ideas, led to a shift towards more conservative and restrictive attitudes towards sex.
In post-war Japan, the country's economic miracle and exposure to Western culture contributed to a more liberal and permissive atmosphere, particularly among young people. The 1960s and 1970s saw a rise in youth culture, with the emergence of Japan's "counterculture" movement, which emphasized free love, pacifism, and social activism.
Contemporary Japanese Sexuality: Challenges and Concerns
Today, Japanese society faces a range of challenges and concerns related to sex and relationships. The country's declining birth rate, aging population, and low levels of sexual activity among young people have sparked debates about the need for sex education and the promotion of healthy relationships.
The prevalence of sex work and prostitution in Japan, while regulated by laws and regulations, remains a contentious issue, with concerns about exploitation, human trafficking, and women's rights. Additionally, Japan's LGBTQ+ community continues to face social stigma and marginalization, highlighting the need for greater awareness, acceptance, and inclusivity.
Conclusion
Japanese sexuality is a rich and complex topic, shaped by a diverse range of historical, cultural, and social factors. From traditional Shinto rituals to modern-day attitudes and practices, Japan's approach to sex and relationships reflects a dynamic interplay between tradition and modernity, cultural values and individual desires.
As Japan continues to evolve and change, it is essential to approach the topic of Japanese sexuality with sensitivity, respect, and an understanding of its cultural and historical context. By promoting open and informed discussions about sex, relationships, and human rights, Japan can build a more inclusive and compassionate society, where individuals can express themselves freely and live healthy, fulfilling lives.
Would you like to make any adjustments or discuss related topics? I'm here to help.
In Japanese media, romance is rarely just about the "happily ever after"—it is a delicate exploration of "mono no aware" (the pathos of things) and the intricate social cues that define Japanese interpersonal connections. From the "slow burn" of slice-of-life anime to the poignant realism of contemporary literature, Japanese romantic storylines offer a unique lens into a culture where what is unsaid often carries more weight than what is spoken. The Art of the Unspoken: "Kuuki wo Yomu"
At the heart of Japanese relationships is the concept of kuuki wo yomu (reading the air). Unlike Western romances that often prioritize grand declarations and verbal clarity, Japanese storylines frequently thrive on subtlety and non-verbal cues. japanese sex
The Power of Proximity: A slight brush of hands or a shared umbrella (相合い傘 - aiaigasa) often serves as the emotional climax of a story, carrying as much weight as a first kiss might in a Hollywood production.
Emotional Restraint: Characters often grapple with honne (true feelings) versus tatemae (public face), creating a natural tension that fuels the "will-they-won't-they" dynamic common in J-dramas and Manga. Common Motifs and Archetypes
Romantic narratives in Japan often lean into specific cultural milestones and tropes:
The School Setting: The "Seishun" (youth) genre is a powerhouse. It captures the fleeting, bittersweet nature of first love against the backdrop of school festivals and graduation ceremonies.
Fate and the Red Thread: The "Red Thread of Fate" is a recurring motif, suggesting that lovers are predestined to meet, regardless of time or circumstance.
Working Culture: Modern "Josei" and "Seinen" stories often highlight the struggle of balancing intense work culture with the desire for intimacy, reflecting the real-world challenges of the declining birth rate and "loneliness epidemic" in Japan. Key Recommendations for the Best Experience
To truly understand these dynamics, explore these quintessential works: Literature: Norwegian Wood
by Haruki Murakami – A haunting look at the intersection of love, loss, and mental health. Film: Your Name (Kimi no Na wa)
– A masterclass in the "Red Thread" concept combined with stunning visual metaphors for longing. Drama: First Love (Hatsukoi)
– A Netflix series that beautifully illustrates how past connections ripple through a lifetime. Anime: Kaguya-sama: Love is War
– A comedic yet brilliant deconstruction of the pride and "face-saving" involved in Japanese dating. The Takeaway
Japanese romantic storylines are essentially a study in patience. They challenge the viewer to find beauty in the hesitation, the silence, and the small gestures. Whether it’s the heartbreaking realism of a Shinkai film or the cozy comfort of a "tea-time" manga, these stories remind us that love is not just a destination, but a series of quiet, shared moments.
In Japan, sexual intimacy is often characterized by high levels of non-verbal and implicit communication Public Affection:
Public displays of affection (PDA), such as kissing, are generally considered a taboo and can make others feel uncomfortable, though these norms are slowly shifting among younger generations.
A 2022 study on university students found that sexual consent is frequently defined as "not saying no," which contrasts with more explicit Western norms. "Sexless" Relationships:
There is a growing social phenomenon of "sexless" marriages in Japan, often attributed to long work hours and fatigue. This theme is so prevalent it has become a popular genre in modern media. 2. The Sex Industry (Fuzoku)
Japan has a unique and complex "semi-autonomous" sex industry known as
Love in the Land of the Rising Sun: Japanese Relationships & Romantic Storylines
Whether you're watching a slow-burn anime or navigating a date in downtown Tokyo, romance in Japan follows a unique rhythm. It is a world where "reading the air" is more important than grand speeches, and a single "confession" can change everything. 1. The Real-World Romance: Traditions & Transitions
Japanese dating culture often prioritizes long-term commitment and emotional depth over casual flings. The Power of
: Unlike the Western "slow fade" into a relationship, Japanese dating typically begins with a formal kokuhaku (confession)
. One person explicitly states their feelings and asks to start a relationship, marking an official "start date". Public vs. Private
: Public displays of affection (PDA) like kissing are largely taboo, rooted in a cultural desire for privacy and modesty
. Hand-holding is usually the maximum extent of physical intimacy seen in public. The Quest for Marriage (
: Marriage is often the primary goal. Many young adults engage in
—active "marriage hunting"—through professional matchmaking events or group blind dates ( Unspoken Understanding : Couples often rely on "reading the air" ( kuuki o yomu
) rather than verbalizing "I love you," which can be seen as unnecessarily direct 2. The Storyline Staples: Anime & Manga Tropes
Romantic storylines in Japanese media often heighten these cultural nuances into dramatic, recognizable tropes.
Navigating intimacy in a Japanese context involves a blend of cultural etiquette, specific terminology, and evolving legal standards. Modern Japanese sexuality is a mix of traditional modesty and a large, visible industry that caters to sexual curiosity. 💬 Essential Communication & Consent
In Japan, clear communication is essential, especially given that a high percentage of youth find obtaining explicit consent challenging.
Seeking Consent: Avoid ambiguity. Use direct questions like: Kisu shite mo ii? (Can I kiss you?) Sawatte hoshii? () "The Tale of Genji" by Murasaki Shikibu "Clannad"
Establish Boundaries: Silence does not mean "yes" in sexual contexts. Use phrases like Yamete hoshii (I want you to stop) to be crystal clear.
Protection: Use Gomu aru? (Do you have a condom?) or state firmly Gomu nashi de yaranai (I won't do it without protection). 🔥 Intimate Vocabulary
The language used in the bedroom ranges from clinical to colloquial. Direct Feedback Motto: More. Soko: There. Kimochiii: It feels good. Motto tsuyoku/hayaku: Harder/Faster. Slang & Terms Reconfiguring sex, body and desire in Japanese modernity
Sexuality in Japan is a complex tapestry woven from centuries of traditional values, modern legal frameworks, and a multi-trillion yen commercial industry. Unlike many Western cultures, Japanese history did not adopt the strict Confucian or Christian views on chastity, leading to a unique cultural landscape where sexuality and marriage are often viewed through different lenses. Historical Foundations of Sexuality
Historically, Japan maintained a relatively open view toward sexuality. During the Edo period, licensed "pleasure quarters" like Yoshiwara were central to urban life, catering primarily to the male elite and celebrated in art forms like ukiyo-e.
Marriage and Fidelity: Traditional Japanese views often prioritize the family unit over romantic exclusivity. Historically, it was not uncommon for men to seek pleasure outside of marriage from courtesans without the same level of social stigma found in more religiously rigid societies.
Post-War Shifts: The Allied occupation after WWII brought significant changes, introducing "sexual liberation" and dismantling militaristic censorship mechanisms. However, this period also saw the rise of organized movements to regulate sex work. The Modern "Fuzoku" Industry
Today, the Japanese sex industry, known as fuzoku, is a significant economic force, accounting for roughly 1% of the country’s GDP. It operates within a distinctive legal "gray zone" shaped by the Anti-Prostitution Law of 1956. Through the Korean Brothels in Colonial Taiwan
Japan's relationship with sex is a study in paradox, blending a historically "open" culture with modern-day challenges like declining birth rates and strict legal loopholes. While traditional perspectives often lacked the taboos found in Abrahamic religions [20], contemporary Japan faces a growing phenomenon of "sexual inactivity" and a highly commodified sex industry [17, 19]. The Modern Dilemma: Declining Intimacy
A significant portion of the Japanese population is shifting away from traditional sexual relationships:
Rising Inexperience: Recent studies show that approximately 10% of adults in their 30s have no sexual experience, and half of those in their mid-20s remain sexually inexperienced [12, 17].
"Sexless" Life: Many young people, particularly women, are rethinking sex and marriage, citing reasons like work pressure, the fear of "bullshit" from men, and the prioritisation of self-care [12, 19].
Alternative Pleasures: A survey by sex-toy manufacturer Tenga found that delicious food is ranked as the #1 source of pleasure in Japan, while sex ranked fifth. The $40 Billion Industry
Despite trends toward personal celibacy, Japan hosts a massive, legally complex sex industry generating over $40 billion annually.
The "Fuzoku" Loophole: While Article 3 of the Anti-Prostitution Law bans "intercourse" for money, many businesses operate legally by offering services that technically fall short of this definition, such as "soaplands," "pink salons," and "image clubs" [30].
Technological Innovation: Japan is a leader in the development of "artificial partners," with growing markets for high-end sex dolls and "lovotics" (love robotics) intended to provide connection and intimacy for those who find human relationships difficult [26]. Historical and Cultural Roots
Historically, Japan's sexual morality was not grounded in Western concepts of sin:
Liberal Origins: In the Heian period, attitudes toward divorce, polygamy, and non-monogamy were relatively liberal.
Shifting Norms: European modernisation post-WWII introduced more rigid regulations and social stigmas regarding public sexuality and prostitution [11].
Public Etiquette: Today, while sex industry advertisements are visible in districts like Kabukicho, public displays of affection (PDA) like kissing are still considered culturally rude on public transit [32]. Legal and Social Reform
Japan is currently navigating significant legal shifts to address modern concerns:
Consent Reform: The government recently raised the age of consent from 13 to 16 and expanded the legal definition of rape to include psychological manipulation and intoxication.
LGBTQ+ Rights: Same-sex sexual activity is legal, and while same-sex marriage is not yet nationally recognised, some local jurisdictions provide "partnership certificates" [31]. Let’s talk about you-know-what - Japan Today
Part II: The Slow Burn of Physicality
Once the contract is signed, physical intimacy does not follow immediately. There is a distinct hierarchy of milestones that narrative media strictly adheres to:
- The Confession (Kokuhaku): Commitment established.
- The Date (Deeto): Usually daytime, structured (aquarium, festival, cafe).
- The First Handhold: Often treated with the same dramatic tension as a sex scene in HBO dramas. In Toradora!, the moment Ryuji holds Taiga's hand is scored with swelling violins and internal monologues of panic.
- The First Kiss: Usually occurs after months (or seasons) of dating, often spontaneously at a train station or under a cherry blossom tree.
- The "Overnight Stay": Rarely shown explicitly; often implied via a fade-to-black and the morning-after awkwardness (asage).
This slowness is not prudishness; it is a reflection of Uchi-Soto (inside vs. outside). Physical touch is reserved strictly for the "inside" circle. Public displays of affection (PDA) are rare because they violate the social harmony (Wa) by forcing private intimacy into the public eye.
Why It Matters
Japanese romantic storylines resonate globally because they offer an antidote to Western romantic saturation. In a world that shouts “Love yourself! Find your passion! Settle for nothing less!”, the Japanese narrative whispers: Love is not a goal. It is a grammar. It is learning to hear the sentence someone is not finishing.
When two anime characters finally hold hands in the final episode—after 24 episodes of blushes, misdirected texts, and walking home 20 minutes out of the way—it is not anti-climactic. It is the most violent, beautiful, earned explosion in fiction. Because in Japan, a pinky touch is not a tease. It is a confession. And the space between heartbeats? That is where love actually lives.
In short: Japanese relationships in storytelling teach us that the most powerful romantic line is often the one no one says—but everyone hears.
Understanding the landscape of intimacy and the adult industry in Japan reveals a complex intersection of history, law, and modern social pressures. From the historic "floating world" of the Edo period to the multi-trillion yen modern industry, Japanese views on sexuality often differ significantly from Western norms. The Modern "Fūzoku" Industry
The term fūzoku (風俗) translates to "public morals" or "customs," but in common parlance, it refers to the vast Japanese sex industry. This sector contributes up to 1% of Japan’s gross national product and operates within a unique legal framework.
Legal "Loophole" Culture: Japan’s Anti-Prostitution Law technically bans vaginal intercourse for money, but many other forms of non-penetrative sexual services are legal. This has led to a highly diversified marketplace featuring: Sources:
Soaplands: Bathhouses where customers are bathed and serviced.
Fashion Health: Parlors offering a range of manual or oral services.
Image Clubs (Ikura): Establishments themed around specific roleplay scenarios.
Love Hotels: These are short-stay hotels designed specifically for couples seeking privacy, often featuring discreet entrances and automated check-ins.
The Hub of Kabukicho: Located in Shinjuku, Tokyo, Kabukicho is arguably the most famous adult entertainment district in the world, thriving on a mix of "night work," restaurants, and specialized kiosks (muryōannaijo). 📜 Historical Roots: The "Floating World"
Sexual expression in Japan has deep historical roots that were not influenced by the same religious or moral constraints found in many Western societies.
Ukiyo-e and Shunga: During the Edo period (1603–1867), erotic art known as shunga (spring pictures) was widely produced. These prints depicted heterosexual and homosexual relations with a level of openness that was uncommon in Europe at the time.
Courtesan Culture: Historic red-light districts like Yoshiwara were officially sanctioned and became centers of culture, fashion, and art.
Tokugawa Era Regulation: While the shogunate attempted to regulate female sex work, it often turned a blind eye to male sex work, which was common among samurai and did not carry the same social stigma.
Japanese romantic storylines are often defined by the "aesthetics of silence"—a unique cultural approach where deep affection is conveyed through subtle gestures and shared understanding rather than grand declarations
. Reviewers and cultural critics highlight several fascinating recurring themes and structural hallmarks that set Japanese romance apart from Western or other Asian media. Dramas with a Side of Kimchi Unique Cultural Hallmarks The Aesthetics of Silence & "Sassuru" : Stories frequently rely on
(sensing or empathizing with others' feelings), where a relationship's beauty lies in understanding each other without words. This can sometimes be polarizing; some viewers find the lack of "skinship" or verbal affirmation frustrating, while others find it deeply poignant. "Kokuhaku" (The Confession)
: Unlike Western dating, which often drifts into exclusivity, Japanese storylines frequently revolve around a formal
("Please go out with me"), which acts as the official starting line for a relationship. Fate and "En" : The concept of
(karmic connection) or the "red thread of fate" is a major driver, often leading to stories about "fated reunions" decades later. Dramas with a Side of Kimchi Recommended Stories & Critical Reviews
Japan’s sexual culture is a mix of deeply rooted traditions and modern practices. For a visitor or someone interested in the cultural landscape, understanding the etiquette, vocabulary, and social norms is key. 1. Important Cultural Norms
Sexual intimacy in Japan often emphasizes cleanliness and discretion.
Hygiene: It is standard practice to shower both before and after sex.
Love Hotels: Since many Japanese homes have thin walls and multi-generational families, "Love Hotels" (often identified by neon signs and hourly rates) are common, private places for couples to meet.
Public Decency: Public displays of affection (PDA) are generally kept to a minimum in Japan. Sexual openness is usually reserved for private spaces. 2. Legal Context & Consent
Age of Consent: Japan raised its national age of consent from 13 to 16 years old in 2023.
Safe Sex: The use of protection is strongly encouraged. You can find high-quality condoms at convenience stores (conbini) or drugstores. 3. Useful Vocabulary
While many people use the English loanword sekkusu (セックス), knowing a few key Japanese phrases can help with communication: "It feels good": Kimochi ii (気持ちいい).
"Let's use a condom": Kondoomu o tsukaimashoo (コンドームを使いましょう). "Stop for a minute": Chotto yamete (ちょっとやめて). "I like you": Anata ga suki (あなたが好き). 4. Modern Dating Dynamics
"The 3-Month Rule": It’s a common (though not universal) dating norm in Japan to wait until about the third date to become physically intimate or "official".
Communication Style: Japanese culture often values kuuki wo yomu (reading the air), meaning partners might rely more on non-verbal cues than direct verbal requests.
Here’s a solid, multi-angle content package on Japanese relationships and romantic storylines, broken down into an engaging blog post framework, complete with cultural insights, tropes, and modern trends.
2. Josei (Target: Adult Women)
- The Arc: Work-life balance, aging pressure, and divorce.
- The Conflict: The gap between Ren'ai (ideal love) and Omiai (arranged marriage meetings).
- The Tone: Realistic. Characters have sex, but they also have morning breath and financial arguments.
- Example: Nodame Cantabile – An eccentric pianist and a perfectionist conductor. Their romance is about professional jealousy and cohabitation without labels.
The trope of the "Dense Protagonist"
Western fans often scream at anime protagonists for being oblivious. "She is literally naked in front of you! How do you not get it?!" This is a cultural translation error. The "dense" protagonist isn't stupid; he is hyper-aware that misreading the air could destroy the social harmony. He refuses to act on physical proximity because, without a verbal Kokuhaku or a clear signal (a blush, a lingering glance), advancing would be a violation of trust.
Conversely, truly romantic moments in J-dramas occur when a character correctly reads the air. In Hana Yori Dango, Tsukasa doesn't need to say "I will protect you." He shows up soaking wet with an umbrella. The umbrella is the dialogue.
The Unspoken Thread: How Japanese Storylines Redefine Romance
In Western media, love is often a declaration—a grand gesture on a rainy tarmac, a shouted confession across a crowded room. In Japanese relationships, both real and fictional, romance is not a thunderclap. It is a slow-motion landslide. It is the inch of a pinky finger sliding across a desk to touch another’s. It is the 0.5-centimeter gap between two umbrellas in a spring shower.
To understand Japanese romantic storylines is to understand ma (間)—the sacred, charged emptiness between things. The pause is not silence; it is the loudest part of the conversation.